Calling for a more inclusive and thoughtful film ecosystem, noted Manipuri film critic Meghachandra Kongbam on Wednesday underscored the need for policies that formally recognise the review and promotion of lesser-known independent films and regional cinema. He was speaking at a roundtable discussion titled “Beyond the Thumb: The Role of a Film Critic – A Gatekeeper, An Influencer or Something Else?” at the 56th International Film Festival of India (IFFI), held in Goa.

Highlighting India’s vast cinematic diversity, Meghachandra Kongbam pointed out that over 2,000 films are produced every year in more than 50 languages, yet only a fraction receive critical attention. He emphasised that without dedicated criticism, many regional and independent films simply disappear from public consciousness.

The roundtable brought together leading critics from across the world, including Barbara Lorey De Lacharriere from Paris,  Elizabeth Kerr from Hong Kong, and India’s own Deepak Gahlot, Sudhir Srinivasan and Baradwaj Rangan, with Davide Abbatescianni from Rome moderating the discussion. The panel explored how the role of critics is shifting amid rapid technological changes, the rise of digital consumption and the dominance of social media verdicts.

Speakers reflected on the growing challenges faced by critics in the digital age, where instant reactions often overpower thoughtful analysis. Sudhir Srinivasan remarked that “the critic’s struggle today is to remain sincere when speed is valued more than depth.”

The panel collectively agreed that a strong critical culture pushes filmmakers to innovate, audiences to think deeply and the industry to embrace diversity. The session ended with a shared belief that while platforms and tools may change, the essence of film criticism remains rooted in curiosity, responsibility and the commitment to champion the full spectrum of cinema—especially those powerful stories that risk being overlooked.